Reviewed by Chad G. Boonswang, Esq.

Most states put limits on how long a life insurance company can sit on a death claim, and many require the insurer to pay interest when it’s late. If the insurer keeps asking for more paperwork, stops returning calls or says it’s “still investigating” months after you filed, you have options. Here’s what I tell beneficiaries to do.

How Long Can a Life Insurance Company Take to Pay?

Once the insurer has a completed claim and proof of death, many claims are paid within 30 to 60 days. State prompt-payment laws generally require insurers to pay, deny or explain the delay within a set number of days, and the deadlines differ from state to state. An insurer can take longer when it has a legitimate reason to investigate, most often because the insured died within the two-year contestability period. I explain why life insurance claims take so long in my full article.

Late Payment Interest: The Insurer May Owe You More

Many states require insurers to add interest to a death benefit that isn’t paid promptly. Two examples:

  • California: If the insurer doesn’t pay within 30 days after the insured’s death, it must pay interest on the proceeds, computed from the date of death. (California Insurance Code § 10172.5)
  • New York: Interest on a death claim generally runs from the date of death until the date of payment. (New York Insurance Law § 3214)

Other states have their own rules, and the rate and start date vary. If your claim was paid late, check whether interest was included.

Steps to Take When the Insurer Is Stalling

1. Make Sure the Claim Is Complete

Confirm in writing that the insurer has everything it needs: the claim form, a certified death certificate and any documents it specifically requested. Ask it to list anything still missing. This removes the most common excuse for a delay.

2. Get the Reason for the Delay in Writing

Ask the insurer to explain in writing why the claim hasn’t been paid and what it’s waiting for. Many state regulations require insurers to give claimants a written status update if they can’t decide a claim within the required time.

3. Document Every Interaction

Keep a log of every call, email and letter: the date, who you spoke with and what they said. Save everything the insurer sends. A clear record makes it much easier to show a pattern of delay later.

4. Be Careful What You Give Them

Respond to reasonable requests, but be cautious about signing broad medical authorizations or giving a recorded statement. Those are usually signs the insurer is looking for a reason to contest the policy, and it’s worth talking to a lawyer before you agree.

5. File a Complaint With Your State Insurance Department

Every state insurance department accepts consumer complaints. A complaint requires the insurer to respond to the regulator, and that alone sometimes gets a stalled claim moving.

6. Talk to a Lawyer

If the claim has been pending for months without a clear reason, talk to a life insurance lawyer. An unreasonable delay can be a breach of the policy, and in some states it can support a bad faith claim.

Why Insurers Stall

Some delays are legitimate. An insurer may need medical records for a death during the contestability period, a final death certificate when the cause of death is pending, or a court decision when two people claim the same money. Other delays aren’t. Repeated requests for the same documents, long silences and investigations with no clear end can all be ways to pressure a family into giving up or accepting less.

If the Insurer Stops Responding Entirely

An insurer that won’t respond at all is a serious problem. Send a written request for a decision by a specific date, keep proof that you sent it, and file a complaint with your state insurance department. If that doesn’t work, it may be time to speak to a life insurance lawyer.

Contact me for a free case review. I work on a contingency fee, so you won’t pay unless I recover benefits for you.