Reviewed by Chad G. Boonswang, Esq.

Yes, you can appeal a life insurance claim denial. How you do it depends on where the policy came from. If the coverage came through an employer, it’s probably governed by ERISA, a federal law with strict appeal rules that can decide the outcome of the case. If it’s an individual policy you or the insured bought directly, state law applies, and the “appeal” may be a request for reconsideration, a complaint to the state insurance department or a lawsuit. Here’s how each one works.

Get the Denial in Writing

If your claim was denied over the phone, ask for the denial in writing. You’re entitled to a written explanation that gives the reasons for the denial and the policy provisions, laws or regulations the insurer relied on. The letter should also explain how to dispute the decision.

Many denial letters are form letters with no detail. If yours doesn’t explain the specific reason, ask the insurer for a full explanation and a copy of the policy, the application and the claim file.

Common Reasons for a Denial

  • The policy lapsed for nonpayment of premiums
  • Misrepresentation on the application, often during the two-year contestability period
  • An exclusion, such as suicide, drug or alcohol use, war or a hazardous activity
  • An AD&D claim where the insurer says the death wasn’t an accident
  • An employer-provided policy that lapsed because the employer didn’t provide conversion or waiver forms
  • A dispute over who the beneficiary is

The stated reason doesn’t always hold up. If the insured qualified for a disability premium waiver they never received, or the insurer can’t show it sent the lapse notices the law requires, the lapse may not be the insured’s fault. When an application error was an innocent mistake, insurers sometimes settle for the death benefit minus the premiums the insured would have paid.

Appealing an Employer Group Policy (ERISA)

Most life insurance provided through a private employer is governed by the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 (ERISA). ERISA requires you to go through the plan’s administrative appeal before you can sue, and the administrative appeal matters more than most people realize.

ERISA Deadlines

  • The plan generally has 90 days to decide a life insurance claim, with one 90-day extension if it gives notice.
  • After a denial, you have at least 60 days to file the administrative appeal. Check the denial letter, since some plans allow more.
  • The plan generally has 60 days to decide the appeal, with one 60-day extension.

(Source: 29 C.F.R. § 2560.503-1)

Why An ERISA Appeal Is So Important

If the appeal is denied and you sue, the court usually decides the case based on the record built during the administrative appeal. Evidence you didn’t submit may not be considered, and in many cases the court gives the plan’s decision deference. That’s why the appeal should include everything: the policy, the records, witness statements, expert opinions if needed, and a clear legal argument. You have the right to request a copy of the plan documents and the claim file before you file.

ERISA also usually limits the recovery to the benefits owed, plus interest and possibly attorney’s fees. Because the appeal shapes everything that follows, talk to an ERISA attorney before you file it.

Appealing an Individual Policy (Non-ERISA)

Individual policies, and some government and church plans, aren’t governed by ERISA. State law applies, and there’s usually no required administrative appeal.

Options Under State Law

  1. Ask the insurer to reconsider in writing, with the evidence that answers its stated reason for the denial.
  2. File a complaint with your state insurance department. The insurer has to respond to the regulator.
  3. File a lawsuit for breach of contract and, where the facts support it, bad faith. Unlike ERISA cases, these can go to a jury and may allow recovery beyond the policy benefits in some states.

Watch the deadlines. Many policies set a contractual deadline to sue, and state statutes of limitation also apply. A request for reconsideration doesn’t always stop the clock.

What to Include in an Appeal Letter

  • The policy number, the insured’s full name, the date of death and your relationship to the insured
  • The specific reason given for the denial, and a direct response to it
  • Supporting documents: the death certificate, medical records, premium payment records, notices or the lack of them, and statements from people with knowledge
  • A request for the claim file and any documents the insurer relied on, if you don’t already have them

Keep copies of everything and send the appeal by a method you can track.

Should You Handle the Appeal Yourself?

You can, but a mistake in the appeal can limit what a lawyer can do for you later, especially under ERISA. I’d rather review a denial before the appeal is filed than after. I handle appeals and lawsuits for beneficiaries as a life insurance dispute lawyer, and I work on a contingency fee, so you won’t pay unless I recover benefits for you.

Contact me for a free review of your denial letter.